In a debate on the Treasure (Designation) Order 2002 there was cross-party support in the House of Lords for the work of the Portable Antiquities Scheme. Lord's also call for the Government to ensure the Scheme's long-term funding.
Baroness Blackstone (The Minister of State, Department for Culture, Media and Sport) praised the Scheme's Finds Liaison Officers, who she said
"have played an often crucial role in helping finders to report their finds and ensuring the smooth running of the (Treasure Act) system".
She added, 'thanks to the (Finds) Liaison Officers, it is already obvious that a significant number of finds have been reported as Treasure that would not otherwise have been', and that 'the Act, with the support of the Portable Antiquities Scheme, has achieved considerable success in mapping, protecting and bringing the general public closer to the more sensitive parts of our archaeological heritage, which would otherwise be lost'.
In reply Baroness Trumpington (Conservative) commented that 'In view of the Government's decision to extend the Act, do they accept the need to provide long-term stable funding for a nation-wide network of Finds Liaison Officers to make it work?'
These concerns were also mirrored by Lord Renfrew (Conservative) who said: 'I also salute the work of the Portable Antiquities Scheme initiated by the department (of Culture Media and Sport). It is splendid news that the number of (Finds) Liaison Officers will increase from the pilot scheme number (of) 12 to 36, to cover the whole of England and Wales. The department has been fortunate and, perhaps, skilful in arranging things so that the Heritage Lottery Fund is covering the expense of the enterprise for three years. However, as my noble friend (Baroness Trumpington) said, there are anxieties about what will follow. I understand that the Heritage Lottery Fund people have said privately that they do not intend to pay for the work for any further period. I ask the Minister for an assurance that her department is examining ways in which the Scheme will continue to be funded after April 2006. It is a national responsibility, and I hope for some encouragement from the Minister that the department regards it as such'.
Lord Renfrew also noted that 'in the debate in the House of Commons Standing Committee on Delegated Legislation, Mr Richard Caborn (Minister for Sport) said that (the Finds) Liaison Officers played, "an often crucial role in helping finders report their finds and in ensuring the smooth running of the system. Thanks to the (Finds) Liaison Officers, it is already obvious that a significant number of finds have been reported as treasure that would otherwise not have been"'. [Official Report, Commons Standing Committee on Delegated Legislation, 16/7/02; col. 5.].
Lord Redesdale (Liberal Democrat) also joined the debate. He praised the Minister for doing 'her utmost to ensure that the Portable Antiquities Scheme will survive in its present form and will be allowed to continue until the start of the Heritage Lottery Fund, which is welcome and will give the Scheme another three years'. However, he added that this 'will lead to a big problem in three years' time because representatives of the Heritage Lottery Fund, in giving evidence to the All-Party Archaeological Group, have categorically stated that they will not fund the Scheme past that three-year limit. That will lead to further debate in the House and to further careful appraisal of how the Government should finance the Scheme.
Lord Redesdale also added that 'it is only right that today we give thanks not only to the Minister but also to those who work with the Portable Antiquities Scheme. The treasure officers (sic Finds Liaison Officers) do such good work in liasing with the metal detectorists. Many metal detectorists do sterling work, not to make financial profit but to protect the historic heritage'.
Baroness Buscombe (Conservative) also reiterated concerns about the long-term funding of the Portable Antiquities Scheme. She said 'it must be made possible to have a sustainable nation-wide network of Find Liaison Officers to support compliance with the (Treasure) Act'.
In her reply Baroness Blackstone gave reassurance to the question of long-term sustainability of the Portable Antiquities Scheme. She stated that 'I was asked about the Portable Antiquities Scheme and whether I can given an assurance that it will receive long-term funding. Like other speakers, I was delighted to know that the Heritage Lottery Fund was able to support the Scheme. That funding will expire in April 2006. In the mean time, I will give the reassurance that has been requested today: that the DCMS will give active thought to the question of the long-term sustainability of the Scheme.
On the question of the revision of the Treasure Act 1996 Code of Practice, the motion was agreed.