Rights Holder: Royal Institution of Cornwall
CC License:
Our images can be used under a CC BY attribution licence (unless stated otherwise).
Unique ID: CORN-C0CDD6
Object type certainty: Certain
Workflow
status: Awaiting validation
Cast copper alloy Roman Kräftig-profilierte type brooch, P-shaped in profile, with a spring and good patina and retaining its pin and catch plate.
Similar examples have been recorded on the database, such as KENT-DA9EA4, IOW-13FD31 and LVPL-1B0623. Kräftig-profilierte means 'strongly profiled'. This type of brooch is defined as a one piece brooch with a spring of around 8 turns. It has a superior chord held by a rearward facing hook above a wide crossbar. The upper bow expands towards a narrower neck at the head and the profile is highly arched and angular above a central encircling moulding. The foot is narrower and curves upwards towards a terminal knob (Bayley and Butcher, 2004, 59). The catchplates are usually triangular like this one and can have up to three perforations. Examples from Britain are rarely perforated, and are believed to be later in the series than perforated examples. Non-perforated examples are possibly British copies of the continental type (Bayley & Butcher, 2004, 59 & 148).
The brooch has a flat widened head that is rolled forward to hold the axis bar of the sprung pin. The axis bar is the widest point on the brooch, measuring 28.5 mm across. There is no gap in the rolled head for a pin lug but instead a single, central lug situated behind the head that encompasses the spring. The pin is intact and complete and held by the catchplate. The bow is wide at the top to accommodate the width of the head and narrows towards a moulded roundel at its base, which is bordered by two ridges and has a central punched annulet, echoed on the foot. The bow is curved, and is a 'D' shape in profile. Below the moulded roundel is a rectangular foot, which curves slightly upwards towards an integrally moulded spherical terminal knop with a smaller raised dome at its tip. The knop is also decorated with a horizontal line of annulet punchmarks. The total length of the brooch is 48.3 mm, and it is 23 mm in depth from the apex of the bow to the edge of the catchplate.
Hattatt (1982, 104) gives them a date of around the first half of the first century AD. This type of brooch is fairly unusual in Britain with only about 50 being known.
Hattatt (2000) illustrates similar examples of Kräftig-profilierte brooches on page 325, Fig.184, Nos.333 & 761, which dates from the 1st century AD.
Bayley & Butcher (2004) illustrate similar examples of Kräftig-profilierte brooches on page 59, Fig.42, Nos. 39 & 41, which date from pre-AD 85 and AD 75-100 respectively.
Notes:
Their origin is thought to be Pannonia, an area around the Danube and Rhine. The 9th Legion had been recruited from this area and then came over to England with the invasion of Britain, bringing the Kräftig-profilierte with them (Simpson; 1979; 330). The known examples from archaeological excavations are mostly from the East and South East of England (e.g. Colchester and Richborough). This has been thought to be because this is where the 9th Legion were based/passed through. They are known to have been at Longthorpe (45-66 AD), Lincoln (66-71 AD) and York, reaching there by 71 and staying until c.120. Twenty-eight of these brooches have been recorded on the PAS database prior to this one, from across the country, from Wales to Kent and Norfolk to Somerset. Due to the small number of this type found in the past, it was thought that they were never actually made in Britain and that they had been brought over to this country by soldiers from Pannonia
However this view is starting to change. An example of a Pannonian brooch was found during excavations at Wroxeter (2002; 103-4 fig 4.7 no 28). The authors of this report say-
"the basic message is that the Pannonian arrived early in small numbers and failed to travel as far as Hod Hill. Wroxeter is one of the few assured finds in advance of the Fosse Way ".
This brooch, along with the others on the database, starts to put into question the idea that the Pannonian type was not made in Britain. It is thought that the Kräftig type is the precursor of the British Trumpet brooch (Hattatt; 1982; 104-7) and alloy compositional studies have also suggested that some of the British examples could have been made here as copies of this style (Bayley and Butcher; 2004; 148). Variations would have occurred as the British brooch makers created their own versions of the Kräftig type and enough similarities can be seen between the trumpet and the Kräftig types to see how the transition to this new form took place.
Bibliography
Hattatt, R. 1982. Ancient and Romano-British Brooches. Dorset Publishing Company
Bayley, J and Butcher, S. 2004. Roman Brooches in Britain: A technological and typological study based on the Richborough Collection. The Society of Antiquaries London.
Simpson, G. 1979. Some British and Iberian pennanular brooches and other early types in the Rhineland and the Decumates Agri. Antiquaries Journal, 59. 319-42.
Webster, G., 2002. The Legionary Fortress at Wroxeter. Excavations by Graham Webster, 1955-1985. English Heritage Archaeological Report 19.
Current location of find: Royal Cornwall Museum
Subsequent action after recording: Donated to a museum
Broad period: ROMAN
Subperiod from: Early
Period from: ROMAN
Subperiod to: Early
Period to: ROMAN
Date from: Circa AD 45
Date to: Circa AD 120
Quantity: 1
Length: 48.3 mm
Width: 28.5 mm
Thickness: 23 mm
Weight: 13.74 g
Date(s) of discovery: Monday 28th May 2012 - Monday 28th May 2012
This information is restricted for your access level.
Museum accession number: TRURI:2020.5
Primary material: Copper alloy
Manufacture method: Cast
Completeness: Complete
4 Figure: SX4351
Four figure Latitude: 50.337947
Four figure longitude: -4.207576
1:25K map: SX4351
1:10K map: SX41SW
Grid reference source: From a paper map
Unmasked grid reference accurate to a 10 metre square.
Author | Publication Year | Title | Publication Place | Publisher | Pages | Reference | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Bayley, J. and Butcher, S. | 2004 | Roman Brooches in Britain: A Technological and Typological Study Based on the Richborough Collection | London | The Society of Antiquaries | 59, Fig.42, | Nos. 39 & 41 | |
Hattatt, R. | 1982 | Ancient and Romano-British brooches | Sherborne | Dorset Publishing | 104-7 | ||
Hattatt, R. | 2000 | A Visual Catalogue of Richard Hattatt's Ancient Brooches | Oxford | Oxbow Books | 325, Fig.184, | Nos.333 & 761 | |
Simpson, G. | 1979 | Some British and Iberian penannular brooches and other early types in the Rhineland and the “Decumates Agri”’ | London | The Society of Antiquaries | 330 | ||
Webster, G. | 2002 | The Legionary Fortress at Wroxeter. Excavations by Graham Webster, 1955-1985. English Heritage Archaeological Report | London | English Heritage | 103-4, Fig.4.7, | No.28 |