2009-01-23 13:23:58 Mark Lodwick mlodwick 2011-07-19 11:15:00 Victoria Wolfe vwolfe NMGW-9C3A27 Brooch Description The reported object is the body of a silver annular brooch; the pin is missing. The brooch has been created by filing down the rim of, and removing the centre from, a silver coin of King Henry VI of England (1422-61); this has created a flat annular brooch with inner diameter of approximately 9mm, outer diameter approximately 22mm, with a thickness of the order of 0.6mm and weight of 2.27g. The brooch survives in two pieces, having at some stage been bent and broken; it has not been cleaned. The 'host' coin is a groat (4d) of Henry VI, struck at the mint of Calais between 1427 and 1434, belonging to either the 'Rosette-Mascle' (1427-30) or 'Pinecone-Mascle' (1430-4) coinages. (Removal of the outer legends in making the brooch precludes a definitive identification.) On the obverse, the King's portrait has been removed, leaving traces of his crown and a border of nine curved arches with fleurs where they meet; on the reverse, there are parts of the arms of a long cross and the inner legend [VIL - ◊ LA - CALI - SIE]. The obverse, and outer reverse, legends have all but been removed in making the brooch. The coin shows a certain amount of wear, but whether this results from circulation or from use as a brooch is not clear. Metal Content English medieval silver coins were struck to a standard around 11oz 2dwt, or sterling silver (92.5% fine). The brooch is most probably silver of around this standard, certainly well in excess of ten per cent precious metal by weight. Discussion Medieval brooches with flat annular frames of silver or copper alloy, bearing inscriptions of religious or talismanic significance, are well known from Britain. The majority of such inscriptions are engraved, but raised lettering is also known. The use of a coin for this purpose is unusual. During the late 11th - early 12th centuries, there was in England a fashion for mounting coins as brooches, with pins and catches soldered to the obverse of the coin so that the cross that formed the reverse design was visible as that of the brooch (e.g., TAR 2003, 78); this continued spasmodically, e.g. TAR 2003, 161, a coin of Henri VII of Luxembourg (1288-1309). The use of coins to create annular brooches can, however, be paralleled by two converted coins of the Teutonic Order from the later 14th - early 15th centuries, which were found in a hoard from Ducker, in Bunge parish (Gotland), deposited in the early sixteenth century (GW/LW/JFD 1997, 370). The most recent of these brooches (post 1414-22) confirms a continuing fashion for annular brooches in the Baltic. That this style of brooch also remained in vogue at this time in south Wales is confirmed by a 15th-century silver brooch from Llandough near Cowbridge, with a raised talismanic formula in black lettering on a frame of similar form (Redknap 1994, fig. 13). Similar fourteenth/fifteenth-century brooches are also known from Ireland (e.g. Co. Meath: Deevy 1998, 109 no. RB 80). The Penllyn brooch, therefore, had all the impact of an inscribed brooch, though the surviving legend had no more significance for the wearer than the garbled versions of religious or talismanic texts sometimes found on medieval jewellery. The main departure of the Penllyn frame from other converted coin brooches, is that no perforation or restriction has been made to fasten the pin. While this feature is not essential, its absence raises the possibility that the conversion was never completed. Another British find of an annular coin-brooch has recently been reported, created from a 'Short Cross' penny of around 1205-9; this lacks its pin, but has been pierced to accommodate one (seen at the British Museum by E.M.B., 10 October 2007). Description The reported object is the body of a silver annular brooch; the pin is missing. The brooch has been created by filing down the rim of, and removing the centre from, a silver coin of King Henry VI of England (1422-61); this has created a flat annular brooch with inner diameter of appro... Treasure considerations Under the terms of the Treasure Act 1996, single coins cannot qualify as treasure; however, individual functional items of precious metal such as brooches, dress fasteners, etc are treasure, providing that they are more than 300 years old when found. In modifying a coin to form an item such as a brooch, it loses its monetary function and status and becomes a functional object. There is therefore a growing series of English precedents for considering a modified coin such as the present find to be a single object qualifying as treasure under Section 1(1)(a)(i) of the Act. This is, however, the first find of this nature to be recorded from Wales since the passing of the Act. Summary and Conclusions A silver annular brooch was created by the modification of a groat of Henry VI of England struck at Calais around 1427-34. The date of the modification is not known, but likely to be during the 15th century. It is our opinion that this object, over three hundred years old when found and comprising more than ten per cent by weight of precious metal, is Treasure under Section 1(1)(a)(i) of the Treasure Act 1996. Silver Struck or hammered MEDIEVAL MEDIEVAL 1427 1500 22 0.6 2009-01-23 13:23:58 VALE OF GLAMORGAN Vale of Glamorgan Penllyn POINT( ) From Map SS97NE SS2917 29.06.2003 Metal detector 1 NMGW Creative Commons Non Commercial Share Alike - The Portable Antiquities Scheme 2009 These records can be reproduced in a non commercial enviroment as long as the original recorder is cited. The Portable Antiquities Scheme info@finds.org.uk No fees are applicable.